Click on link for details and to share your thoughts and to vote on idea:
http://ipbhoops.com/index...&id=1326&catid=16

| Author | Comment | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
irfan |
DC IPNBT 2009 - New Format Idea - Need your Vote |
Lead | ||
|
Click on link for details and to share your thoughts and to vote on idea:
|
||||
|
|
||||
dbandits30 |
#1 | |||
|
Irf,
You are looking to make DC into a glorified pickup game which goes away from practicing and playing as a team. The whole idea of winning a Championship is to do it with your players and your team, not other players from all over the United States and canada. Thoughts... |
||||
|
|
||||
dbandits30 |
#2 | |||
|
Irf,
Did you delete your previous post? In any case, let me respond. When will you admit that the old IPB is dead. Those guys don't care about anything but themselves. They look for posts to promote themselves. Many don't even come to the board anymore. They have more pressing things to do than give back to IPB. The new order is Indopaksports like what is happening in Dallas and Florida. Where players can show off their talents to more than 10 teams, where people have passion for the game. You saw it in Dallas with the B league and the football. Throw in other sports like volleyball and soccer and now you are in front of over 50 teams in a given weekend. You yourself tried to get a 30 and over tournament for the same people you still have faith in and what happened. You had to cancel the tournament because IPB as is is just not important to them. I ask you to promote the Indopaksports concept and lets bring our community together through sports and not just basketball. Those guys don't care anymore. Ice
Last Edited By: dbandits30 11/08/08 04:20.
Edited 1 time.
|
||||
|
|
||||
kinghndlz |
my opinion | #3 | ||
|
it says 12 teams 7 man roster...so say its like the ordinary tourney and 12 teams come down with their usual 8-10 guys but with this 2-3 guys wont be able to
play from each team now this brings the point dont u want more ppl playin in these tourneys but instead u r turnin some away and it also says u evaluate a dude
by their past accomplishments and role on their team now what if the guy is new to the scene and hasnt established a rep yet but is good and can hang with the
comp but how will the gms know to pick him up...i think its a cool idea but i think there are more cons then pros and also say u were to do it with the draft
this year can someone come up to dc as a free agent lol im bein serious tho like can one dude from dallas come up and get drafted even though his team aint
registered for the tourney let me know if u dont understand what im tryin say so i can elaborate
|
||||
|
|
||||
irfan |
#4 | |||
dbandits30 wrote: Ice, The goal of this new format is to try and bring the #1 goal of IPB back front and center. Which is to help IPB Basketball Players build friendships with other IPB basketball players from around North America. You complain about "Super Teams" this will eliminate Super Teams and actually even the playing field where each "New" team of 7 will have to work together as a team in bracket play to build chemistry to make the playoffs. The top level talent will be distributed among the 12 teams. This should also help solve the problem of people not watching the games since members of the original team will stick around to watch and support those teammates play on the new teams. Also it will help get the board buzzing again leading up to the tournament since all player bios and picks will be posted and done before the tournament on the board. I don't think IPB should be afraid to try something new. If it doesn't work out IPB teams still have Chicago, Dallas, Toronto, Vancouver, and NY tournaments that they can attend afterwards with their original teams and go back to the old format. Now, as far as old IPB vs new IPB I dont see much difference as far as participation of players. Leading up to Dallas the board was buzzing a little, but after the tournament very little was posted by the "New" players who participated. Not even a simple thank you by these new teams that came out and attended!! That is sad. Same thing as far as watching the games go it was the usual size crowd that would come and watch the games. You talk about the passion of playing the game. The guys who are for trying this new format are definitely playing for the "Love" of the game and the spirit of IPB, since they just want to play and don't mind playing with new players to try and win a Championship and building new friendships...wouldn't you agree? As far as being able to hold multiple sports at one tournament, its great that Dallas and Florida have the facilities and the manpower to pull it off and I hope more and more teams come out to participate. But not all tournaments have the facilities you have and we do the best with what we have just like all other tournaments do. I hope you come out to DC and help support the tournament format if we do go for this new format. |
||||
|
|
||||
irfan |
#5 | |||
kinghndlz wrote: There will be 84 spots to fill and it registration will be based on first come first serve. So if one team gets their entire 10 man roster to sign up and each player pays their tournament fee then they are in. With the rosters being limited to 7 players it assures each member of the team will be getting PT. The evaluation of players by the DC committee will only be done to identify the top 12 players in the pool of 84 and to make them the GMs. This will evenly distribute these top players among the 12 teams. As for new players to the scene if they sign up they will be posting a little player bio describing their skills and they will be picked so they will have a chance to show their talent in this tournament. Every idea has its Pros and Cons. Again its just an idea and all feedback helps us make our decision. Thanks for your feedback. |
||||
|
|
||||
dbandits30 |
#6 | |||
irfan wrote:
Irf,
First let me apologize for jumping the gun, because I think it's great to try new things and think outside the box. You have presented some good points that have validity but I offer my counter. 1) The tournament is limited to 84 players so in one way, you go away from the Super team, but in reality you create 12 super teams. 2) The concept of team and practicing and working hard to win is thrown right out the window. Teams can't run systems, it becomes a glorified pick up game. 3) The concept of building IPB is limited to 84 players who are probably the same 84 who would have been there in the first place. What happens to the other 30-40 players who would be on teams had you not use this format. 4) Coaches like myself, Matt, Sterling, and Yourself, what is there to gain for us to spend money to travel to the tournament and have in reality no impact on the game because it's a glorified pick up game. Players don't need coaches in pickup ball. Now to address some of yoru comments: 1) Instead of this discussion web, at least 20 of the 34 total teams contacted me after the tournament through email and facebook. Almost every B team did, but not as many A teams but still many did. So I am Ok with that feedback. 2) I agree on the resources and I agree that we are blessed with the opportuites that we have to offer, but that doesn't mean it can't be done in other sites. I just don't think any of the other cooridinators want to do it as they prefer to not take risks and stay with what works for them now. THis year, we knew it was risky to have multiple sports, but the opportunity to bring more people together in a community setting was worth the risk. Sonu and I went on 3 hour sleep, but it was worth it. 3) When you practice and earn your spot in the tournament, there is a sense of self reward and accomplishment. That is what si missing in IPB. When IPB was at it's strongest, it was that effort that made the reward special. Teams didn't just go out and get the best players from teams all over the US and claim superiority. They worked for their championship and when they won, there was a feeling of accomplishment. Now, teams are made up of merceneries who go to the highest bidder. Entire IPB teams would create bonds with each other. They would work and sacrifice together. We don't have that anymore. We need to get that passion back. |
||||
|
|
||||
irfan |
#7 | |||
dbandits30 wrote: Ice, You make good points as far as the cons go. But like you took risks to do more sports for your tournament we are looking at taking a risk and trying something new as well.
1. We would love to have more then 12 teams made up of 84 players and if we get enough interest to add more teams we will look into doing that. This is just a starting point not a fixed cap. 2. I disagree that teams are not going to be able to run some sort of system. The teams will have 5 games to play together to gel. It is up to the team to work together to come up with the best game plan. Some teams will be able to pull this off and others might not. That is the samething we see in IPB now. Some teams have systems and other teams dont. 3. You bring up a good point about coaches like you, Matt, and myself not having any impact in this format. Maybe we can look at making some of the coaches GM's as well. It's a good suggestion. At the end of the day its an idea that we are working on refining to make it better and enjoyable for all players that participate. So keep the suggestions coming and we should be able to tweak this idea so that it becomes that.
|
||||
|
|
||||
dbandits30 |
#8 | |||
|
I am all about taking risks because I think you only get better. So I commend you on that. However as your friend, I am telling you that you have too much
faith in the old IPB player and teams. Lets just say that 5 players from a base team (ABC TEAM) are all selected on different teams. I promise you that the
other 4 are not all going to stick around and watch their teammates play. As soon as they lose, they will leave with their mos tlikely destination home on an
earlier flight.
I understand what you are trying to do and apart from buying their attendance with rebates like Chicago, the modern day player will leave as soon as they lose. You even left as soon as the football tournament was over saturday night in Dallas even though you played with Kush's B team who made it to the final 4. Three of the Pillars players were on that team, but even you did not make it a priority. Many times, it is not the players choice, but their friends who want to leave and that si their only ride. With the exception of Tampa one year when the tournament was delayed for two hours, the Bandits as a team have stayed until the announcements are over and have even helped clean up because it was the right thing to do. It was out of respect for every tournament cooridinator and the teams that were playing in the finals. Most of the time we were in at least the semi finals, but even when we didn't even make it to Sunday our players were in street clothes at the finals. That is the respect we have for IPB but I am not sure that respect is returned, so chances are we have seen our last final unless we are playing in them. In Dallas, we are no longer handing our all- tournament awards because players don't even care to stick around to get their own awards and you expect them to sit around all day in a gym and cheer their buddies. I don't think it will happen, but I will applaud the risk and out of the box thinking.. |
||||
|
|
||||